CD Review: John Carter

Disney has faced an uphill battle marketing its new film, JOHN CARTER. Based on Edgar Rice Burrough’s 1917 novel A Princess from Mars, the studio has endured negative press for months surrounding focus groups, changing titles, and the dilemma of how to present a sci-fi/fantasy film based on a century-old book that few people have even heard of, much less read.

Forget all the pre-opening manhandling and online vitriol. JOHN CARTER is a thoroughly entertaining, if imperfect, film that should give genre fans plenty to enjoy, whether it’s eye candy leads Taylor Kitsch and Lynn Collins or the film’s evocative art direction and eye-popping special effects (which probably would have looked less fuzzy in 2D). The script by director Andrew Stanton, Mark Andrews and Pulitzer Prize-winner Michael Chabon (The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay) somehow conjures up emotion out of the Red Planet’s dust and alien characters. But Stanton excels in the film’s cracker action sequences with their Pixar sense of dramatic pace. Michael Giacchino‘s score is quite simply breathtaking, a thrilling throwback to heroic film scores of yore.

Giacchino’s heroic main theme is one of his finest, giving the film and the score a musical identity that is sorely missing from recent genre films. Whether mysteriously voiced in the cellos and string tremolos in “A Thern for the Worse” or pumped up to its full brass glory in the rousing Western homage in “Get Carter,” the theme conveys the many facets of Carter’s personality, from disillusioned Civil War vet to confused alien and unlikely hero.

Giacchino gets great mileage out of al parts of the theme, including deconstructing the three-note motif at the beginning of the melody for an aural calling card. In “Gravity of the Situation,” the theme becomes airborne in a Straussian waltz (Richard, not Johann) of buoyant musical wit as Carter gets his Mars legs.

The heir apparent to John Williams once again channels his legendary predecessor in tracks like “Sab Than Pursues the Princess.” As the winged ships battle it out in the sky, percussion battle it out in the recording studio with a churning lower-string ostinato and furious sixteenth-note figures in the violins, woodwinds and xylophone. As John Carter leaps into the air to catch the princess, the musical action suspends in mid-air to a thrilling, heroic rendition of the main theme before returning to its intricate orchestral furor.

Sab Than Pursues the Princess

Click Track: Sab Than Pursues the Princess

Fans of Giacchino’s action music will find much to appreciate with thrilling set pieces like the nail-biting wedding sequence “The Prize Is Barsoom” (introducing a bold new choral and brass theme in the film’s third act), the rousing “Fight for Helium,” and the surprising epilogue, “Ten Bitter Years.” In “Carter They Come, Carter They Fal,” Stanton weaves together another alien battle with Carter’s memories of his wife on Earth. As the sound effects are dialed down, Giacchino’s strings and wordless chorus take center stage in a gut-wrenching and heartbreaking threnody of pain, loneliness and loss.

Carter They Come, Carter They Fal

Click Track: Carter They Come, Carter They Fal

Whether on metal or drums, Giacchino’s use of percussion in tracks such as “The Second Biggest Apes I’ve Seen” and “The Right of Challenge” gives the score a primal, tribal force that is alien yet familiar. Though apparently even the Tharks have heard of “moaning woman” over 55 million miles away, thankfully Giacchino doesn’t overplay his hand with this overused trend in contemporary scoring.

As enjoyable as Giacchino’s score is on disc, it deserves to be heard in context of the film—booming out of huge multiplex speakers and supplying that vicarious thrill that only great film music can. Stanton allows Giacchino generous visual and dramatic space for his music and the composer delivers. When it all wraps up in a spine-tingling, heroic major chord over the final title card, I defy you not to stick around for the end credits, if only to experience the glory of this fantastic score in a nine-minute suite (the final track on the album) that I’m sure will be featured on film music concerts for years to come. JOHN CARTER is the first great film score of 2012.


  1. Well, now this sounds like great film music. My reaction was not heir to John Williams but Jerry Goldsmith. Not that either comparison matters, but I have been very critical of the way action movie scores are all too often underplayed as if the composer or director has no faith in the power of music to enhance the film. I look forward to hearing the rest of this score.

  2. i’m a big fan of Giacchino, but not of this score (i listened to many other tracks on youtube)

    i’m just scratching my head over this one – wondering what other people are loving so much and wondering what Giacchino was thinking with his musical choices

    guess i’ll have to be the lone killjoy

  3. ah Jim- thanks so much for once again opening up my ears to a score i might have otherwise ignored. Giacchino is definitely the next new John Williams…

  4. John Carter score is as boring as the movie.
    Even with Giacchinos 6 orchestrator’s attempt to give gloss to this re hash of tired action and melodramatic cues,
    Harry Gregson Williams is on a different level. to bad we have to hear the same composers over and over again. Listen to Jerry goldsmiths planet of the apes if you want to hear inspiration.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *